Newporter 40 Together

a beautiful boat should sail forever.

But boy did I learn a lot! Below is an unedited description of the learning process!

Casting A Rudder Heel Bearing: The difference between failure and success
Well, it turns out that the rudder heel bearing cast was a little more difficult than I grasped. My first casting was a failure - as far as the casting itself was concerned - but what an incredible educational opportunity. I had been trying for years to engage my brain to learn about casting, but just could get no traction because I am an experiential learner. Once I got my hands dirty, learning went into superdrive. Everything made sense.
So consider the rudder heal bearing anatomy - a slanted back wall and a slanted "socket" for the rudder post to sit in. Now consider the mold half with the plug for the socket, as well as the back wall. There is only one direction that the pattern will lift out after that half of the mold is formed - and then only if the back wall of the pattern and the socket walls are parallel. You could, however, lift the template and break the plug off, and then reglue the plug.
The reason the first casting failed was my lack of understanding, a lack of how molten metal behaves as it solidifies. Molten metal solidifies from the outside in. The walls of the mold absorb heat from the metal closest to them, and as the heat is absorbed the metal solidifies, with the interior isolated pockets remaining molten the longest. This fact leads to a fundamental visualization model of THE PATH OF SOLIDIFICATION, which includes not only space but time as well. A successful casting starts with a pattern whose design has incorporated the consequences of THE PATH OF SOLIDIFICATION.
The failure of my first attempt at casting the rudder heel bearing is a perfect example of making a pattern that did not consider the PATH OF SOLIDIFICATION. Consider the shape of the original heal bearing. The aft portion has some relatively sophisticated curves that appeared to be a lot of work, so I just simplfied the pattern to have thicker walls and no pattern, reasoning that it would be less work, and stronger as well. WRONG! It turns out the those thick walls created a massive, isolated pocket of molten melt that solidified very slowly - well after the rest of the bearing had solidified and was CONTRACTING. The stress put on the molting internal pool created what is known as a "hot tear", somewhat a akin to a fissure in a glacier, right in the bottom of the socket. So those curves on the back of the original mold were not for looks. They were to keep all the walls close to the same thickness, which would allow uniform cooling with no late cooling pocket of molten metal.
It also did not help that at the bottom of the socket two wall meet. That focuses the stress from both walls, making the junction a likely place for a failure. So radiusing all intersecting walls is another fundamental rule of pattern making. And I did add a radius of JB Weld in the second pattern.
One last mistake I made, as another consequence "of over designing" the pattern, was that I did not have enough bronze to complete the pour. Sort of ended up with a 9/10 height bearing on the first try. That was ok, but there was another consequence. Even the original heel bearing had walls that were thicker in some places than than others. To deal with this situation, one makes sure that that PATH OF SOLIDIFICATION never blocks off the path of incoming molten metal to these isolated pockets. Then even as the rest of the solidifiying metal contracts, more molten metal is coming into the area. When the whole mold is full you should still have a "reservoir" in the spru cup that feeds the space created by the contraction of solidification. Since I did not have enough metal, there was no reservoir.
If you want to get into casting I highly recommend the U. S. Navy Foundry Manual.

Rating:
  • Currently 0/5 stars.

Views: 81

Comment

You need to be a member of Newporter 40 Together to add comments!

Join Newporter 40 Together

Comment by Eddie Offermann on July 24, 2015 at 9:31pm

Boy, you've been up to a lot since I was last on!

While I'm not doing casting at this scale at the moment (I've done a small amount in the last six months or so that I provided CAD for but farmed out the actual casting process), it's interesting to read your experiences since I'm really interested in picking that part of the task up myself at some point.

            LINKS ===============

THE ROSTER

Muf, our Keeper of the Roster, has updated it.  But he still needs information on boats out there that he doesn't have, like new owners, old owners, where any of the boats are.  We don't post the roster on the web site, it is only sent to owners.  Please send him anything you might have, or call him at:      

gmuf48@aol.com   

909 561 4245

===============

Captain Clyde's Newporter  sites:

newporters.blogspot.com

and  

newporter.ning.com

The Ning site has been given a reprieve.   I have  transferred my Ning site to the blogspot site and will leave it there. I am keeping my Ning site open as a home for my photos and drawings.

Many of my photos there do not relate to Newporters, but a search through my collection may prove useful for your studies.

My drawings are not accurate in many respects as a result of the PAINT program used to draw them, There is no accurate scale and at best they are only useful to indicate some specific detail.  Some are inaccurate because of my poor memory.  Use them to help you think, not as a detailed presentation of the subject matter.

If any of you want to start a web site I suggest you remember what has happened to both my Ning site and this site (which is a Ning site) and remember that my Blogspot site is free and Blogspot's owner (Google) has promised to keep it that way.

 

Clyde's email:

camgphil@msn.com 

Put 'Newporter' on Subject Line.  Email is the best way to contact me.  I do not regularly look at this site or its messaging system.  Email will get to me post-haste. 

===============

© 2024   Created by bob mitchell.   Powered by

Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service